JOIN OUR
MAILING LIST

Do three star reviews actually matter?

Title card reading Three Star Reviews Are Sh*te, yellow and orange capitals on deep purple.
On this page

Not really. But they really do hurt, and consider yourself clickbaited.

The three-star review epidemic feels like it’s been growing in recent years. In the lead up to the Fringe I warn anyone I can that even though it makes no sense, they sting. And every year, we all forget our logic and they sting.

The upbeat, logical, objective, true part first.

3 stars is a good review. No matter what you think about them, they’re objectively good. 2.5 is half of 5. Meaning 2.5 isn’t even bad. 2.5 is a bang average show. Which isn’t exactly good, but it’s not BAD, it’s bang average.

Meaning 3 stars means “yeh, good show”. It means “I would recommend this show”. How many shows have you seen that sure, didn’t CHANGE YOUR LIFE FOREVER, but you enjoyed them, you’re happy you gave them your ticket money, and you’d recommend them to a friend?

Now the less upbeat, more shitty, but hopefully a bit validating part.

They really sting.

They shouldn’t, but they dooo.

In the last few days I’ve felt more stung by really nice 3 star write-ups than by actually quite shitty 2 stars. A quite shitty review, you go, ok cool, the show wasn’t for this person, and that’s fine. But the quite nice three feels MADDENING. Like WHY ISN’T IT A 4.

But one person thinking your show is “pretty good” just cannot have more weight than the sold out room thoroughly enjoying themselves, or the comedian you really respect saying you’re fantastic, or any of the other glowing 4 and 5 star reviews.

Either they all matter or none of them do, and you kind of need to pick.

So if you’re having the three star review meltdown, you’re not alone. Have a bitch about it to your pals, then, in whatever way you can, move on. No offence, but your show getting one 5 star review doesn’t make you the BEST COMEDIAN ON THE ENTIRE PLANET, FUCK EVERYONE ELSE. So a three star review doesn’t make you a bad comedian either.

KP
Katie Palmer

Founder of Brass Tacks Comedy, a Scotland-based, female-founded comedy production company producing stand-up across the UK and Ireland, and at the Edinburgh Fringe every August.

Keep reading

More like this
Janey Godley in glasses, a red patterned headband and a colourful jumper, against a sandstone wall.

Brass Tacks Comedy announces ‘The Janey Godley Fund’ for Scottish comics

Comedian Ashley Storrie is funding a Fringe run for a Scottish comedian in memory of her mum, Janey Godley. Applications are open now.
Read more
Grace Mulvey in a fluffy pink cardigan and white heart-shaped sunglasses, shrugging with both hands up against a pink backdrop. Gigantica UK Tour 2027.

Grace Mulvey announces 2027 UK tour

Grace Mulvey is touring her latest hit show, Gigantica, round the UK from February to April 2027, and tickets for all seven dates are on sale now. We’re Brass Tacks Comedy, and we produced Gigantica at Assembly at the Fringe

Read more
Chris Forbes in a Santa hat, wrapped in red paper, standing in a snowy landscape

Chris Forbes announces Father Christmas tour for 2027

Chris Forbes is taking Father Christmas on tour round Scotland and Newcastle in February and March 2027. Tickets go on sale at 9am on Thursday 15 October (Glasgow is on sale already). Christmas is coming early this year. This Fringe

Read more